Monday, April 15th, 2013

Reality Bites

Reality Bites

Bad movie – great line…the notion that every once in a while events, circumstances, occurrences, the randomness of life gets in our way – gunks up the works – screws us up – flushes our plans down the toilet and otherwise creates a F@#k Fest.

Here is the thing – what is reality?

Seriously…

I’m not trying to be esoteric, metaphysical, philosophical or transcendental…honestly.

But I have come to see that my view of reality is skewed – distorted and one-sided – in short, biased by where I live, what I have experienced and what I believe and/or have been taught is the perfect outcome of life as a result of a perfect and rational process (another one-sided view…).

And so even the phrase “reality bites” has taken on new meaning for me – what bites is that there are so many different realities, so many different outcomes, so many different paths, and oftentimes we look at them and want to impose our view, our reality…because the others seem so wrong…so bad – but frankly, to those living them they might in fact be just the thing.

Let me get specific.

My liberal, left-leaning, champagne socialist politics and outlook have a distinct “save the world” hue and needless to say it’s save the world in my distinct image of how the world should be saved.

All good until…”Reality Bites.”

Last week I had the amazing privilege of visiting Senegal with UNICEF. Wisely, they called it a “Field Visit”…and not a mission. I joined a small group of committed UNICEF board members and staffers and we spent four days looking, listening, experiencing and mostly learning.

I won’t bore you with the history of the country – but it is worth reading up on – particularly as Dakar was a center for the slave trade that so infected the Americas for some 300+ years, and seeing an infamous “Door of No Return” at a still-standing slave trader’s home made it very up close and uncomfortable for me.

I will share this though – as this is where my story starts – poverty is widespread, with 33.5% of the population living on less than $1.25 a day. Children are the most affected – it’s a country with a booming population – and a UNICEF study showed that three out of five children in rural areas and in families where there is little education, have no access to essential services – and we are talking housing, medicine, education – and nutrition.

Sadly, child abuse, begging, rape and the general lack of basic services are a “Reality” in Senegal – but on the other hand, a host of programs have been fielded to deal with these issues and more – and the good news is that there is progress.

Theatre in school to teach about rape

A few stories where my “Reality” was challenged:

We visited a school – a few in fact.

They were truly inspirational.

Kids learning, teachers teaching, hopes and dreams being created with every possibility of fulfillment.

Dedication from parents, teachers and administrators – in fact, everything you and I would want for our own children.

The Local PTA

Confession:  At first I assumed this was bad – imagine my kids here? – never. Sand-blown playing fields, lack of supplies, torn posters warning against child molestation or disease or begging.

"No Begging"

Then I looked at the kids’ notebooks, the slates they were working on. Meticulous notes, beautiful handwriting, the same subjects that kids their age were learning everywhere. Happy faces. Animated. Full of life.

Learning to Write

This is in fact their “Reality” and it doesn’t bite – not in the way I was thinking. Of course it could be better and believe me, the kids, their parents and all are working to make it so.

In fact, the student government in one of the schools is run by an elected president (a second grader…he will run the country one day), who is assisted by a prime minister and a full cabinet of specifically appointed ministers, including one for sanitation and one for culture.

School President, 2nd Grade

We visited a village where we were given the local rural version of a PowerPoint presentation detailing the ten-year-plan the village has for its future, including building an infirmary and a high school. Dreams, and a plan to fulfill them.

Ten-Year Powerpoint Plan

On the very downside, we saw a Dara – run by a marabout, where 60+ children lived and learned in one small room – in filth and stench – begging for their meals and the money that goes to the marabout, and where social service agencies have to create devil’s deals in order to provide the kids with medical or other attention. And while this was the low end of the Dara system, the begging is widespread.

The Dara

We saw hospitals where two doctors specializing in malnutrition care for a population of hundreds of thousands, and we saw child protection facilities run by retired volunteers who are near unto saints.

And finally, we visited a program run by the NBA and sponsored in part by Nike, where kids get to accelerate their education and also play sports in order to develop the leadership skills so necessary for the future of Senegal.

SEEDs Sports Academy

Gorgui Dieng, a member of the winning Louisville Kentucky NCAA team in the US, came out of this program.

So…”Reality”? You judge – the “Reality” that bit me was that I wasn’t there to change their reality – on the contrary — I needed to understand how I could take mine and help them make theirs better as they wanted it and not replace it.

And to that end…listen:

“Imagination is the one weapon in the war against reality.” Jules de Gaultier

We saw the imagination, we saw the dreams, we saw the determination – they are fighting and will win – I have no doubt. And hopefully we will too….

What do you think?

  • David - you had the privilege in this experience to have your mind and your reality broadened and deepened. I am glad you blog about it, so we can in turn, reflect, broaden and widen our thinking, and be incentivised to act, to 'realize'. This world and all its people are our collective responsibility. “There is no Them. There are only ...
Monday, April 8th, 2013

“To be, or not to be…”

“To be, or not to be…”

What the hell kind of question is that?

Poor sentence structure–not clear…to be what?…or not to be what?

No one talks that way, Will! Write it over or you will never get anywhere…don’t worry, we will help you develop it the right way….

Imagine that William Shakespeare had to submit his prose to a new software grading system developed by edX, “that uses artificial intelligence to grade student essays and short written answers, freeing professors for other tasks.”

According to Anant Agarwal, the president of edX (a nonprofit joint venture of Harvard and MIT) and by the way, an electrical engineer, students should not have to wait days or weeks to receive their grades. Instant feedback will help them learn quicker/better, and the ability to submit and resubmit until they get it right makes a powerful tool.

“O Romeo, Romeo!  Wherefore art thou Romeo?”

Romeo? What kind of name is that, Will? And why repeat it? No, no. Keep at it…you will get it right….

Dr. Agarwal was quoted as saying “there is a huge value in learning with instant feedback. Students are telling us they learn much better with instant feedback.”

Yes, and no doubt that is true. Put your hand on a hot stove and the point is made….

And, clearly multiple-choice tests have always been about quick feedback to level set knowledge gains…but getting the facts right does not equate to wisdom.

Nor does having a computer grade essays–which are reflections (or should be) not of knowledge as in facts…but of wisdom…synthesizing facts and a million other variables into something unique and wonderful, and human.

Frankly, I can’t imagine what is more important for a teacher/professor to do than to be individual with every individual–even if it takes time–that’s the point of teaching, no?

Do we want to create generations of homogenized people–who write and think and dream the same way?

Software can be magic, but at the end of the day software is only loops of code and routines that interact with the data it encounters. And the written word is not data–not in that sense.

We are losing perspective here. The beauty of humankind is that we all have that little bit of unpredictability, that edge of what the hell, that carpe diem ability that confounds the best shopping software and drives impulse purchases–not to mention creates Shakespeares and Einsteins and you and me.

Read about edX, see what you think–I find the premise wrong and the output dangerous and counterproductive.

Imagine if your first kiss had been graded on a computer, or your first…you get the point….!

In a “big data” world where more and more tech leaders are calling for more and more human insight, I find this so-called “advance” to be way out of touch.

Listen:

“I would trade all my technology for an afternoon with Socrates.” Steve Jobs

And lucky for us edX never graded Socrates….

“In the beginning….”

God! God…will you ever learn to write?

What do you think?

  • You raise many good points, especially about creating a homogenized culture. But the thing I believe is the bigger question doesn't surround the implementation of edX, but deciding whose voice will the voice the algorithm deems "right". It doesn't seem to be a stretch to say that because this program is written by Harvard and MIT, it will a) hold ...
  • Great article. Learning is optimised when conversaitons are started. And had. And software cannot yet create a conversation with nuance, tone, personality (one worth connecting with at any rate). I understand the point of grading but I think grading comes better from a human rather than a benchmarking system. I remember those teachers whom had a big influence upon my life. Not ...
Monday, April 1st, 2013

Does Facebook Know it’s Mobile?

Facebook is a mobile company. Already. FULL STOP. In fact, as much or more so than AT&T or Vodafone or Telefonica or whatever local carrier you use in your country or region. In fact, as much as Google or Microsoft or Samsung or Nokia – only different.

So I am mystified by the digibabble and speculation surrounding a potential Facebook phone – whether a good idea or bad is a secondary issue – and the continued chatter and noise that refuses to acknowledge what is versus the continued hope for what might make money for investors with little or no value for users like you and me.

First and foremost – more photos and status updates are posted to Facebook from mobile sources than from computers – DUH!!! Why is this a surprise? Why is it even written about? If all we did was sit at our desks…think about how boring life and Facebook would be…we are all out and about – restaurants, shows, museums, movies, stores (yes…stores), parks, vacations, sports events, you name it – with our friends, significant others, families – whomever – OF COURSE WE POST…that is the point – NO?

Cell phones began our liberation and smartphones continued our exodus from slavery to freedom. No longer were we chained to cables and no longer were we limited to voice calls.

The carriers were at a loss – they wanted greater value than they could get from a mere pipeline – they wanted to charge premium prices for the data they carried – and while they were the original abolitionists of the tyranny of place – they became complacent…collected fees and engaged in price wars. Meanwhile the Googles and Apples of the world were re-imagining the way we untethered.

Search went local – as did we – and as we go, so goes Facebook and Instagram and just about every other social platform idea you can think of – not to mention those that were created to be obviously walkabout like Foursquare, Waze and OKCupid, which allows people to scout dates based on their location.

Bottom line: Facebook is mobile – as mobile as you and me. What they haven’t figured out is how to charge for it – make money from advertising – create bigger shareholder value…although I’d bet most of us agree that user value is still fairly high….

All of which leads us to the matter of the Facebook phone. WHY? Limit development to one maker of hardware? Limit access to holders of a piece of plastic and metal? CRAZY!

Access is in fact the new ownership – who cares what hardware I have so long as I can access the Facebook platform? Make me better apps, more useful sharing tools and YES, please figure out how to deliver me the right advertising in the right way so you can make some money and continue to develop your platform and not end up charging me for access….

GUYS – follow the content…please – don’t follow the analysts who still don’t get what mobile is….and who only want to drive stock price, not user value…Listen:

“The only reason I made a commercial for American Express was to pay for my American Express bill.” Peter Ustinov

I hope that Facebook doesn’t lose the plot….

What do you think?

  • David, totally agree. FB has been late to the game in figuring out that everything is mobile, when I am sitting at my desk it is only another view into my connected world. Until recently FB mobile client did not allow for me to create a group! It said go to a computer...at least that is fixed. I have been using ...