Archive for June, 2011

Monday, June 27th, 2011

Creativity

I’m sitting here watching the sun come up over the Mediterranean – bringing the Cote d’Azur to life, as that unique blue sky merges with the beautiful blue sea.

Lest you think that I am extremely obsessive (another story…, deeply linked to natural phenomenon or crazily workaholic getting up so early in such a beautiful place) let me reassure you – full confession – that I haven’t been to bed yet.

You see, last night was the final Awards Ceremony of the 58th Annual International Festival of Creativity – better known by its universal moniker The Cannes Lions – and let’s just say I’m feeling my age….

The Lions brings together people from all over the world; people from across every business category; clients and agencies and media; people from every strata – from the Heads of Major corporations to college students in a structured program on creativity to everyone in the middle and top to bottom – all united under one theme – Creativity…defining it, celebrating it, understanding it, evangelizing it…learning, teaching, improving and ultimately creating a full and rich culture around it.

I encourage you, dear reader, to follow the links and look at the work – see what the entrants thought was good; see what the judges thought was best; see what you think and what you like – did you agree with the choices? Were you inspired?  Would you share the ideas and learn from them?

Overall I’d personally say yes. I think that the Film Jury hit the bull’s-eye (full confession, it was chaired by my friend and business partner Tony Granger), and I do think that some of the other juries missed the mark on some key categories – but that is what makes this such a great event – it’s the passion for the work and the discussion around what is truly great.

But here’s the thing – I don’t want to write about the work – make up your own minds on that front – and report back…rather, I’d like to comment on the event itself and the atmosphere it creates and fosters – and no I don’t mean the Gutter Bar or Carlton Terrace…alone….

I am always struck by the lack of respect shown for others at some International Sports Forums. You know what I mean – when national pride or regional bias or bigoted hatred raises its ugly head and fans yell obscenities and worse at the other team; where people refuse to play against others – you know what I mean – it has even touched pro tennis and the Olympics.

I don’t have to tell you about the situation at various NGOs. Entities created to help mankind exclude some or another and too often, again, hatred is the fodder for growth.

Crazy.

At Cannes, though, it’s the opposite. No matter who wins – everyone applauds. No matter what country, region, religion or nationality – somehow all find their way to the same parties, sit on the same juries, participate in the same events, get passionate and fired up about the subject of creativity and yet never cross the line to where it gets personal.

I have thought about this over the years and have written about it too, but somehow this year – as I began every morning watching CNN share the latest spewed hatred – it stuck out even more.

So why is it? Why is this community that has been my professional home for over 30 years seem to have transcended the divisions of our world and instead found the connectors?

I wish I had an answer – in fact, hoping that you might have some – but here are some conjectures.

Is it because globality and sharing are what unite us through consumers – as in people?

Is it because it’s insights into behavior that drive us and our work – and when you look at yourself and others “naked” in the light of behavioral study – ugly is really ugly?

Or is it somehow linked to our creative selves – the very fuel that drives us?

To that end – I stared Binging – the concept, thought, idea of creativity linked to everything from harmony to peace to community to unity – and on and on.

You can imagine what I found – lots of Zen stuff, lots of New Age, lots of bad examples. I kept at it – and then a quote popped up – from a very basic and primal literary source that stopped me in my tracks.

Listen:

“And God created man in His image; in the image of God He created him; male and female He created them.” Genesis…the Bible

I was stunned – took me a moment – let’s be clear – this is not about religion – certainly not about fundamentalism – it’s about a thought.

The Bible begins with creativity – and the notion of looking at your work with a critical eye – the original Lions Festival….check out this piece in the recent Harper’s Magazine

As I read this – it talks about mankind – not people from one neighborhood or another or people from one belief set or another and certainly not about one person versus another – it seems pretty clear…at least to me – creativity is about all of us – not just any one of us.

And maybe – just maybe that is in our business DNA – we are a business about people – about understanding people, about connecting with people – maybe just maybe some of that original thinking of creation wormed its way into our subconscious.

Who knows?

But let’s hear what you think…

And to end – let me call out the final piece of work shown at the festival – that I believe makes the point.

Monday, June 20th, 2011

Power Abuse

If you don’t know all of the names, please follow the links – interesting that all have cause to fear the digital age….

What do Anthony Weiner, Dominique Strauss-Kahn, Bashar Assad and Robert Mugabe all have in common?

Power abuse.  Plain and simple.

Add to that list Eliot Spitzer, Hosni Mubarak, Radovan Karadzic and Ratko Mladic, the Taliban and Al Qaeda, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Bernie Madoff and a host of other abusers on every continent, in every country, even in every city…I would imagine.

Here we are in a world connected – like it’s never been connected before – with technology that has the potential to solve problems and save lives…not just kill bigger and better…and yet it’s like we have learned nothing.

What is truly amazing is that in the digital age it seems to have gotten worse – or maybe it’s just that we hear about it quicker and more globally.

Or maybe folks think that the digital that empowers all of us – empowers them a bit more.

But here’s the thing – in the globally connected digital world it takes but a few clicks to find that a former New York State governor and a former World Bank president used the same call girl service – talk about a small world….

Bottom line – the truth is and maybe even the good news is – that at the end of the day digital media might have finally democratized the world – even if we haven’t figured it out yet.

So while some may plot to kill and others to show their “wares” – while the vast majority are happy to shop and share – we are all part of, and vulnerable to, the same basic digital pathways.

All of which reminded me of an old proverb I heard many years ago…listen:

“Once the game is over, the king and the pawn go back in the same box.” Italian Proverb

And there you have it – to my mind the true beauty of the Internet.

King or pawn – we all have the same ultimate accountability – as we always should have – but in today’s world – it can be tracked and traced….

Think about that, Anthony and Dom….

What’s your view?

 

 

Monday, June 13th, 2011

What Is An Idea?

What is an idea?

Seriously – what is an idea?

And when does an idea cross the road and become more – something real, tangible, useful, valuable – you get the picture.

I ask – out of all seriousness – having just read a piece in Tech Dirt that looks at ideas vs. intellectual property (IP):

The impetus for the question and their look at it is a web site called http://ideasmatter.com that has been created by Philips, Microsoft and DSM in an effort to better define the need for protecting IP.

Their manifesto states:

“Ideas Matter is a consortium of cross-sector enterprises, small and medium-sized businesses and trade associations that aims to expand awareness and promote the benefits of intellectual property (IP). We firmly believe that IP—and the ideas that lie underneath them—are important to the economy, important to society, important to companies both large and small. In other words, Ideas Matter.”

Listen to the language carefully: “…IP and the ideas that lie underneath them…”

The manifesto goes on to say:

“Despite its importance, intellectual property (which includes patents, design rights, trademarks, domain names and copyrights) remains a complex and often misunderstood topic.”

Again – listen carefully: IP “remains a complex and often misunderstood topic.”

Notice it doesn’t suggest that ideas are a misunderstood topic…HMMMMM.

Thought we might begin by looking at definitions – and there are no lack of them.

IDEA — noun

1. Any conception existing in the mind as a result of mental understanding, awareness, or activity.

2. A thought, conception, or notion: That is an excellent idea.

3. An impression: He gave me a general idea of how he plans to run the department.

4. An opinion, view, or belief: His ideas on raising children are certainly strange.

5. A plan of action; an intention: the idea of becoming an engineer.

6. A groundless supposition; fantasy.

Bottom line – its all in the mind; all in the realm of imagination; all speculative – and despite its being a noun, not real.

Now let’s look at the definition of Intellectual Property also a noun:

Property from original thought protected by law: original creative work manifested in a tangible form that can be legally protected, e.g. by a patent, trademark, or copyright”

See the big difference?

IP is tangible – it’s real – its 3D – it can be touched and felt; it’s material and physical – you get the point.

And, as such, it can be and should be protected. In fact, it is – IP is not open source – it is not “free fishing” – and I personally am a huge believer in fully applying the law to real IP.   

For example I won’t use bootleg downloads of music; books; movies – whatever – not only because I believe it’s a moral and ethical issue – but because I believe that if we don’t pay for great stuff, great stuff won’t happen – and frankly – I don’t know about you – but the thought of having to watch hours of stupid video vs. one Lord of The Rings – is frankly depressing.

And – to be really clear the notion that the Digital world is built on giving it away for free is no different than it was when Print was invented, or recordings – the debates raged – but lucky for us and global culture and knowledge – the safeguards were put in place.

We all know the famous verse from Ecclesiastes: “There is nothing new under the sun.”  And the notion that there are only really seven basic plots in all literature — a contested number to be sure, but all agree that there is a limit.

So imagine if Steven Spielberg got sued by the original Anglo-Saxon author of Beowulf – for “idea” infringement on the similarities between Jaws and Grendel. I guess lucky for Steven the author isn’t known and lived in the 700s.

So there you have it. Did the Winklevoss have a case against Zuckerberg? Do we think that ideas and IP are separate and distinct? Should everything be free?

Found this great thought – listen

“A revolution is an idea which has found its bayonets.”
Napoleon Bonaparte

And maybe therein lies the answer.

IP is an idea which has found its bayonets…..

How do you feel?

Do you download bootleg?

Do you think there is a difference between an idea and IP?

These are critical issues that I do believe affect the development of the future of great ideas and powerful IP.

Final thought – the Internet was created to share scientific knowledge…….

Share your thoughts – ideas…..

PS – I was going to write about the nexus of privacy; bad taste; public trust and pure sheer piggishnessthe story of Anthony Weiner will have to wait….

  • Digital is not always free -- and in the future possibly even less so. Soemone pays -- somehow. It is my view that the printing press was actually the revolution and that all that follows is an evolution -- the revolution being the possibility to share information -- not hoard it as had been the case in most of the ...
  • Really dont agree that the digital world is no different than when Print was invented. The main difference is that digital is instantaneous and free, when print was invented it was for a much narrower audience (remember most couldnt read) and was only available to those who could afford education. even today print is not available for free in many ...
  • Maybe the answer starts with a question: Is all ideas equal? Sharing basic ideas on facebook about your cheese burger is equal to sharing breakthrough idea on the world or on a new product? Or idea about love? Or song or software. The Internet allows for the first time for all ideas to be published. is all ideas equal in ...